TO BE AN EFFECTIVE INTERVIEWER

 

¡¡

By Mr. Jason Li, Researcher Onpress Shanghai

Jason Li has a B.A. in English Language.  After graduation, he joined Onpress International and currently works as a Researcher in Onpress Shanghai office.


Conducting proper, face-to-face interviews are the most important element of the hiring process; there is little question that a skillfully handled interview can differ a successful hiring decision from a costly hiring mistake.  The interviewer, obviously, plays a key role in the process of the interview.  What makes an effective interviewer?  Based on the professional knowledge and experience, the writer gives his own thoughts on how to be a good interviewer.

 

First of all, the interviewer must have a full understanding of the need of the company. 

 

What is the position?  Sometimes, the interviewer comes across some positions that he/she has never heard about.  Then the interviewer needs to gather related information.  Generally, he/she needs to read some materials and finds out some typical examples.  And talking to the person who is or was at the same position would be helpful.  For example, a company needs a Six-Sigma Master Black Belt.  Not many of the interviewers know Six-Sigma.  If you are one of them, you should learn something about it.  You may go to the library to read through the relevant books, or talk to Six-Sigma experts through the internet.  Or if you have a friend who knows Six-Sigma pretty well; it can save you a lot of time. 

 

What kind of persons does the company need? This is very important.  Only understanding the position is not enough.  It would be good to interview the people who will work with the appointee.  Their ideas could help form a image of the appointee. 

 

The key is to know clearly about the company¡¯s requirements.

 

Now, the interviewer has known what kind of people the company needs and it is time to switch to the candidate¡¯s side.  Usually, to read the candidate¡¯s resume is the first step.  By reading carefully the resume, the interviewer could have a profile of the candidate in mind.  Then, based on both the company¡¯s needs and the profile of the candidate, the interviewer needs to make an interview strategy; in another words, to prepare for the face-to-face interview and make sure that the process of interview will be under control. 

 

Before we get into the face-to-face interview phase, I¡¯d like to highlight a very important thing:  An effective interviewer never pre-judges.  Logically, we cannot have a conclusion before we do the research.  However, some interviewers do not work this way, which may cause bad effects to the recruitment, or even failure.  

 

Talk to the candidate and focus your attention.   Please note that here we use the word ¡°talk¡± but not ¡°inquire¡±.  We must be ware that while we are questioning the candidate, they are observing us as well.  Interviewers can never ask questions like the lawyers do in the court.  Tom Peters once noted that, ¡°If a person is going to be uncomfortable in the company, the discomfort will start during the interviewing process and candidates that don¡¯t fit in will generally leave of their own accord.¡±  What an interviewer needs to do is to build a rapport with the candidate.  It is always a communication exercise in which both sides can exchange ideas freely.  A good interviewer is an excellent listener.  It is impossible to learn anything of value about the candidate without listening.  In short, he/she should know how to listen----more specifically, he/she should know how to listen actively. 

 

Asking questions can help the interviewer get the wanted information.  It¡¯s time to ask the prepared questions.  A good interviewer is not afraid to ask tough questions; he/she probes for complete answers.  He/she is able to do so, however, without alienating the person being interviewed.  In addition, talking to the referees is another good way for information.  Sometimes it helps the interviewer understand more or fully about the candidate.

 

The interviewer must also make sure that the provided data are true so as to evaluate the candidate effectively.  It has to be pointed out that, the questions so often asked, which have been the bedrock of job interviews----¡°Tell me about yourself,¡± ¡°How did you like (or dislike) your last job?¡± ---- run the risks of producing answers that candidates have prepared in advance to make the most favorable impression.  And it is also hard to hear impersonal comments from the referees.  As a good interviewer, he/she has to analyze the information carefully, and pick up the useful.  We¡¯d better always remember:  ¡°Garbage in, Garbage out.¡±

 

The above are some ways of getting the effective data.  However, data are limited.  No matter whether it is admitted or not, the interviewer¡¯s intuition also plays a very important role in the evaluation of a candidate.  ¡°Intuition is a mode of understanding, a knowing characterized as direct and immediate and occurring without conscious thought.¡±  ¡°Intuition is nothing more and nothing less than recognition.¡±  We have to say, a good interviewer¡¯s intuition is formed by his/her own experience and genius.  That¡¯s why it is said that:  ¡°Novices see information in pieces; experts see large patterns.¡± 

 

In conclusion, a good interviewer is focused, well-prepared and experienced.  He/she fully understands the process of interview; he/she knows exactly what kind of employees the company needs; he/she could build a rapport with interviewees and draw out the information skillfully; he/she is good at analyzing; he/she knows how to use his/her intuition.  It takes time, anyway.

  

 

 

Bibliography:

 

1.www.cfenet.com/Downloads/ IntuitionandtheInterviewProcess.ppt

 

2.The Fast Forward MBA in Hiring: finding and keeping the best people,

 by Max Messmer

 

3.The McKinsey Mind, by Ethan M. Rasiel, Paul N. Friga